How Holo Lane Prices a Card: Evidence-Tiered Discounts, Explained

November 16, 2026 · Explainer

Every single in the shop is priced the same way: take what a PSA 10 copy is worth, list the raw card at a discount off it — sized by how much graded-sales evidence backs that PSA 10 figure. Here's the method, what it doesn't promise, and why printings matter.

Onix — Base Set #56/102

Onix — Base Set #56/102. One of the 123 singles priced by this method.

Every card in the Holo Lane shop is priced by one method, and it is written on every listing: a discount off the card's PSA 10 value, sized by the evidence behind that figure. No exceptions, no quiet markups, no "was $X" strikethroughs. This is the whole method, in the open.

What PSA 10 means

PSA is the largest third-party card grader. It scores cards from 1 to 10 on centering, corners, edges, and surface. A 10 — Gem Mint — is the top of the scale: a card with essentially perfect centering, sharp corners, clean edges, and a flawless surface. It is the ceiling of what a card can be worth, because it is the best copy of that card that exists in a slab.

That ceiling is also a market price. Graded copies sell publicly, and those sales are tracked — PriceCharting is the reference we use — so for most cards, there is a real number for what a PSA 10 copy is worth right now. How strong that number is depends on the sales behind it: some PSA 10 figures rest on dozens of graded sales, some on one or two, and some on no recorded sales at all. That difference is what sets the discount.

The method

For every card we list as a single, we take the PSA 10 market value and list the raw, ungraded card at a discount set by the evidence behind that figure: 80% of PSA 10 where 4 or more graded sales back the figure, 65% where only 1–3 sales do, and 50% where the figure is unverified or estimate-only. Our Fossil Psyduck, for example, is listed at $255 — 50% of its $510 PSA 10 value, because that figure has no graded-sales evidence behind it yet. Team Rocket's Mimikyu is $220 against a $440 PSA 10, and Ditto from Crown Zenith is $181.62 against $363.23, for the same reason. Same method, every card, all 123 singles.

The two lots work differently. Cards with no verifiable PSA 10 figure anywhere — the bulk of the collection — go into the Energy lot and the Bulk lot at their raw value instead. They are not singles, and they are not priced as if they were.

Why a discount — and why it varies

A raw card is not a graded card. That is the entire reason for the discount, and it cuts both ways.

Grading costs money and takes time, and the outcome is never guaranteed. A raw card might come back a 10, a 9, or an 8, and nobody — not us, not any seller — can promise which one before it is graded. The discount is the gap between "might be a 10" and "is a 10." The size of that gap follows the evidence: a PSA 10 figure backed by 4 or more graded sales is a solid number, so the discount is 20%. A figure with only 1–3 sales behind it is thinner, so the discount is 35%. A figure with no sales evidence at all — or one that is only an estimate — is the least certain, so the discount is 50%. If you buy a card here, grade it, and it comes back a PSA 10, the spread between our price and the PSA 10 value is yours. If it comes back a 9, that is the risk you took with your eyes open. We would rather you know that before you buy than after.

Printings matter

The same card can have a different PSA 10 value depending on which printing it is — and the difference can be enormous. Take our Fossil Psyduck: the 1st Edition printing has a PSA 10 value of $1,132, the Unlimited printing is $510, and the 1999-2000 print is $355. Same card, same art, three different values.

That is why we say which figure we used on every listing. Our Psyduck is priced on the Unlimited figure of $510, at 50% because that figure has no graded-sales evidence behind it yet. If you are buying a card anywhere — here or anywhere else — and the seller cannot tell you which printing the price is based on, that is a question worth asking before you pay.

Values move

PSA 10 values are market values. They go up and down with demand, with new sets, with the hobby's moods. Our price is set when the card is listed, from the figure and the evidence available at that time. It does not chase the market up or down day by day.

What we don't do

No invented "was" prices. No fake markdowns designed to make a price look like a deal. No promises that a card will grade a 10. The price is the price, the figure behind it is shown with the evidence that backs it, and the card is raw and ungraded unless we say otherwise.

The catalog, by the numbers: 123 singles, each priced at an evidence-tiered discount off its PSA 10 value — 80% with 4+ graded sales behind the figure, 65% for thin evidence (1–3 sales), 50% where the figure is unverified or estimate-only — plus an Energy lot of 84 cards and a Bulk lot of 927 cards at raw value. All in, $9,781.78.

Browse the full catalog →

If a price here ever looks wrong to you — too high, too low, based on a figure you can't find — tell us. The method only works if it survives being checked.

← Back to the Bugle